- What does arbitrary shift mean: The employee says "I will choose this shift from the allowed options" and records the choice at that moment.
- Key simile: Like choosing a seat in the ticket sales system; The empty seat can be selected and the filled seat is disabled for the next person.
- Capacity role: If there is a shift capacity, it can be selected, and if it is completed, the possibility of selecting it is closed for new people.
- Legislation: Pre-defined rules and capacities apply to one's choice; In both methods, the rules of the set are above individual choice.
method What is the desired shift? A choice similar to choosing a ticket seat
Imagine entering the ticketing system: you see a map of the hall, empty seats are highlighted in bright color, sold seats are gray and unclickable, and you can only choose from available seats. Desired shift In the Axis Puls system, it works exactly with the same logic, and it is the second main method of registering a shift request in the system. In this method, employees directly choose their desired option from among the shifts that can be chosen for them according to the rules. The list that each person sees is not a list of all shifts in the department; It is a list that the system allowed for the same person after applying the rules, capacities, role of the person and the conditions of the department.
The fundamental difference between this method and the proposed method is in "decision time". in Suggested shift, the employee registers his preference and the final decision is made about each person's place in the layout stage; But in the desired shift, the decision is made at the moment of selection and the system controls the capacity and rules immediately. This feature makes the desired shift an attractive option for parts that want a quick, transparent selection process without waiting for the setup step. This method, like all system components, is part of the bigger picture shift management and gives a more favorable result when the rules and capacities of the department are carefully defined in advance; A topic whose basics are in the article Shift adjustment has been checked.
How is capacity controlled? Full option disables
The simplest and yet most important arbitrary shift rule is the capacity rule: if there is a shift capacity, that shift is selectable, and if the capacity is filled, the selectability is disabled for new people. This behavior has three practical effects. First, Avoid congestion; No shift is filled more than the defined ceiling and the staff mix in each shift remains within the department's standard range. Second, Transparency for employee; Before choosing, a person sees which options are open and which are closed, so he does not waste his energy on unrealistic options. Third, Justice in Access; Because the capacity is filled in the order of the actual selection, no one can take the place of the person who selected earlier by ordering outside the system.
🟢 Option with
capacity A shift that is still available is viewable and selectable by eligible individuals.
⚫ completed option
A shift whose capacity is full will be disabled for new people and it is not possible to select it.
👤 Role condition and section
Each person will only see shifts that match their approved role and membership category.
📏 time ceilings
The daily, weekly and monthly limits of each person also affect the permissibility of each option.
The subtle point is that "capacity" in the system is not just a general number; Capacity can be defined based on role, gender and specific conditions of each shift. For example, a night shift may have a total capacity of six people, but at least two of them must be nurses; In this case, when the nursing quota is filled, that shift will be disabled for the next nurses even if the overall capacity is still available. It is this accuracy in the definition of capacity that transforms the arbitrary choice from a "simple reservation" to a "rule-based choice". To learn about the monitoring mechanism of these capacities after selection, the article Shift control And for the general framework of working hours, the article Working hours They are good supplementary resources.
The rules of the set are above individual choice
The most important thing to remember about custom shift is the same thing in the product documentation: In both methods, the rules of the set are above individual choice. This means that freedom of choice in the desired shift is not absolute freedom; Freedom is within the law. Pre-defined rules and capacities are applied to the individual's selection and the employee can only choose from the options that the system has recognized for him. If a shift is inconsistent with a person's weekly cap limit, that option will not be displayed or disabled for them; Even if it has empty capacity. If a shift is specific to another role, the person will not see that different role in their list.
This design is a direct response to a common concern of managers: "If we leave the choice to the staff themselves, what about covering the hard parts?" The answer is that coverage of the hard parts is maintained through the "correctly defined capacity and rules" path, not through the "disallow selection" path. For sensitive shifts, the manager can fine-tune the capacity, define stricter role requirements, or specify the minimum composition of each shift; Then people's free choices are automatically made within this safe framework. This is why the quality of the arbitrary shift is directly tied to the quality of sector legislation: the more realistic sector legislation, the less risky the freedom of choice. The experience of nursing departments in this field in the article Nursing shift management and the basic principles of legislation in Shift adjustment It is explained.
Voluntary shift does not mean "everyone can take any shift they want"; It means "everyone chooses from among the options allowed by the laws". Freedom of choice becomes meaningful within the framework of the law.
The difference between the preferred shift and the proposed shift at a glance
Comparing these two methods, it is better to start from the employee's own language. In the proposed method, the employee says: "I prefer these shifts"; Then the system checks everyone's requests and arranges the schedule. In the desired method, the employee says: "Among the allowed options, I choose this shift"; And the system controls the capacity and rules at the same moment. In the first method, the final decision is made in the layout stage and with a comprehensive view of the manager; In the second method, the decision is made at the moment of selection and with automatic control of the system. In the first method, prioritizing 1 to 3 means expressing the intensity of desire; In the second method, the main tool is "choosing among the allowed".
- If you want to see all requests at once and balance the final composition yourself, the proposed method with layout engine and re-arrangement option is more suitable.
- If you want to make a quick selection without waiting for the layout and to control the capacity in real time, the desired method is more responsive.
- If your department is crowded with a mix of sensitive roles, combining both methods in different periods can give more flexibility; The final decision is with the department manager.
- In any case, the prerequisites of both methods are the same: the precise definition of the department structure, roles, shifts and capacities before the start of registration.
The final point of this comparison is the same principle: in both methods, the rules of the set are above the individual's choice, and the final decision is to approve the program with the administrator. The system does not take the place of the manager in any of the two methods; It just makes the path to the decision shorter and clearer. Full description of the first method in the article Suggested shift Read on and see to see where both methods fit into the overall process Shift Management Guide come back If your workforce consists of service and support shift workers, articles Staff shift and shift workers can also complement this study.
Steps to start the desired shift and summarize
The start of the desired shift starts from the same point where all system processes start: the structure definition. First, the department, required roles, shifts and the capacity of each shift are defined once in the system; Then the employees become members with the specific code of the department and the role of each person is confirmed by the manager. After that, the selection window is announced and each person takes his shifts from among the virtual options allowed by the system. Each selection is immediately checked for capacity and rules, and at the end, the administrator checks and approves the completed view of the application. If a change is needed after approval, the path to continue in the article Leave and shift management It is explained.
In conclusion, the arbitrary shift can be considered as "law-based trust in the individual's choice": instead of tying the hands of the employee, the system creates a safe framework within which free choice does not harm the coverage of the department. The analogy of choosing a ticket seat conveys exactly the same feeling; You are free to take any empty seat, but you cannot sit on a sold seat and you cannot enter a hall for which you do not have a ticket. This simplicity and transparency increases the participation of staff in the planning process; Because each person sees that his choice is immediately and without mediation in the program. To take the next step, read Comprehensive Guide to Shift Management And talking to the product team about a two-month trial is the logical way forward.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions about Preferred Shift (FAQ)
Experience free choice within the law
Try for two months in the real conditions of your collection and then decide.
Start of trial period